KeepOnSinging wrote:

gabriele wrote:

Snakes do need to be pried off carefully so as to not hurt them.    ​   But you're right, KOS, I wouldn't chose one as a pet. 

Those were so good Gabriele.

These are my three.

My two older children share the same birthday three years apart.
My mother's youngest grandson and youngest granddaughter share the same birthday three years apart.
My SIL shares his birthday with my parent's wedding anniversary.

 

 ​Hmmmm.....  I'm not sure I'm allowed to have a turn.  But if so, I'd say there is something 'strange' with the statement #2, as it either says the same as #1 or you would otherwise call the people in #2 more fittingly your 'niece' and 'nephew'.  I conclude that it is a decoy and number three is wrong.    But in true Jet style,  I'm probably overthinking this by miles.    ​  

KOS' statements were on one page on my computer...gabriele's response on the next page.  So before I even saw gab's I was narrowing my eyes and pondering those two first statements too!!

I think they may be the same.  It could be that KOS has only to children - and her two "older" children ARE her mother's youngest grandson and granddaughter.

You think YOU are overthinking this, gabriele??   LOLOL

So I would probably have said that #3 is wrong also.  But since gabriele has chosen it (and we aren't really disallowing anyone a turn)

 
I will say # 2 is the lie.


Btw, in our family we have quite a few of those odd, shared birthdays too...which seems funny in light of all the days in the year.  

Last edited by View, unobstructed (6/08/2016 7:50 am)

View, unobstructed wrote:

KOS' statements were on one page on my computer...gabriele's response on the next page.  So before I even saw gab's I was narrowing my eyes and pondering those two first statements too!!

I think they may be the same.  It could be that KOS has only to children - and her two "older" children ARE her mother's youngest grandson and granddaughter.

You think YOU are overthinking this, gabriele??   LOLOL

So I would probably have said that #3 is wrong also.  But since gabriele has chosen it (and we aren't really disallowing anyone a turn)

 
I will say # 2 is the lie.


Btw, in our family we have quite a few of those odd, shared birthdays too...which seems funny in light of all the days in the year.  

#2 is not the lie.  But kudos to both you and gabriele because I had not noticed, when I wrote these statements, that #1 and #2 could be the same two people. 
 

KeepOnSinging wrote:

View, unobstructed wrote:

KOS' statements were on one page on my computer...gabriele's response on the next page.  So before I even saw gab's I was narrowing my eyes and pondering those two first statements too!!

I think they may be the same.  It could be that KOS has only to children - and her two "older" children ARE her mother's youngest grandson and granddaughter.

You think YOU are overthinking this, gabriele??   LOLOL

So I would probably have said that #3 is wrong also.  But since gabriele has chosen it (and we aren't really disallowing anyone a turn)

 
I will say # 2 is the lie.


Btw, in our family we have quite a few of those odd, shared birthdays too...which seems funny in light of all the days in the year.  

#2 is not the lie.  But kudos to both you and gabriele because I had not noticed, when I wrote these statements, that #1 and #2 could be the same two people. 
 

So #1 is probably the lie.

 

vmmmomof3girls wrote:

KeepOnSinging wrote:

View, unobstructed wrote:

KOS' statements were on one page on my computer...gabriele's response on the next page.  So before I even saw gab's I was narrowing my eyes and pondering those two first statements too!!

I think they may be the same.  It could be that KOS has only to children - and her two "older" children ARE her mother's youngest grandson and granddaughter.

You think YOU are overthinking this, gabriele??   LOLOL

So I would probably have said that #3 is wrong also.  But since gabriele has chosen it (and we aren't really disallowing anyone a turn)

 
I will say # 2 is the lie.


Btw, in our family we have quite a few of those odd, shared birthdays too...which seems funny in light of all the days in the year.  

#2 is not the lie.  But kudos to both you and gabriele because I had not noticed, when I wrote these statements, that #1 and #2 could be the same two people. 
 

So #1 is probably the lie.

 

You are right:  #1 is the lie Vmm.  It is a lie because my two older children were born on the same date two years, not three years,  apart.  My daughter arrived three weeks late, according the doctors, and my older son arrived two weeks early.  Same hospital, same doctors, same nurses, and even the same bed in the same room.  It was surreal but fun.

#2 Their brother, the singer, does share his birthday with his cousin Amy who is three years younger.

#3  And my SIL was born on what would have been my parents 32nd anniversary had my dad not died five years before in 1965.

Your turn Vmmm.
 

Last edited by KeepOnSinging (6/08/2016 12:54 pm)